Sanjay Raut Apologises to CJI Surya Kant, Must Appear on Nov 17

Deshbaani News : Rohit Dhiman

Oct. 29, 2026 11:57 a.m. 41
Sanjay Raut Apologises to CJI Surya Kant, Must Appear on Nov 17

New Delhi: Shiv Sena (UBT) Rajya Sabha MP Sanjay Raut has reportedly submitted an affidavit tendering an unconditional apology over remarks concerning Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant and the judiciary. However, the apology has not yet resulted in the closure of the proceedings against him. The Supreme Court has directed Raut to appear personally before it on November 17, 2026, at 2 pm in a criminal contempt case linked to his alleged public statements about the Chief Justice and the judicial institution. The matter came up for hearing on October 28 before a bench comprising Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi. During the proceedings, the court was informed that an affidavit had reportedly been filed on Raut’s behalf. However, the document was not available on the court record at that time, and no lawyer appeared before the bench to represent him during the hearing. Considering the circumstances and the wider institutional questions raised by the petition, the court directed Raut to be physically present at the next hearing. The direction remains significant even though reports published on October 29 stated that he had submitted an unconditional apology.

Why Has the Supreme Court Directed Sanjay Raut to Appear Personally?

The direction for Raut’s personal appearance followed the October 28 hearing, when the bench examined the status of the responses expected from both individuals named in the petition. According to reports of the hearing, the Supreme Court was informed that advocate Vishnu Sharma had filed a vakalatnama, a document authorising a lawyer to represent a party in court. The court was also told that a reply affidavit had been submitted on Raut’s behalf. However, the registry’s report indicated that the required appearance had not been formally recorded, and the affidavit was not available in the court file during the hearing. This meant the bench could not proceed on the basis of a reply document that was not before it on the record. The court directed the registry to check the status of the relevant papers and ordered Raut to attend the next hearing in person. The order does not, by itself, mean that the court has rejected his reported apology or concluded that he committed contempt. Instead, it establishes that his physical presence is required when the matter is taken up again.

The next hearing is scheduled for November 17, 2026, at 2 pm.

Sanjay Raut’s Reported Unconditional Apology: What Is Known So Far? Reports published on October 29 stated that Raut had filed an affidavit offering an unconditional apology to the CJI and the judiciary over his remarks. The reports also indicated that he had expressed a lack of intention to insult the court. An unconditional apology generally means that a person offers an apology without attaching conditions to it. In contempt proceedings, however, the submission of such an apology does not automatically end the case. The court must consider the circumstances, the contents of the apology and the stage of the proceedings before deciding what legal effect it should have. In Raut’s case, an important procedural distinction remains. During the October 28 hearing, the bench was informed about the reported affidavit, but a copy was not available on the court record. The subsequent reports about its filing do not establish that the Supreme Court has accepted the apology. The court has not announced a final decision on the contempt allegations. Nor should the reported apology be treated as proof that the proceedings have been withdrawn or that the matter has been resolved.

Read Also: Indian Air Force Plans New Helicopters for VVIP Transport and Security

What Is the Case Against Sanjay Raut About?

The proceedings arise from a petition filed by the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) over public remarks attributed to Raut and journalist Nikhil Wagle concerning CJI Surya Kant and the judiciary. The controversy reportedly followed the Chief Justice’s decision not to hold an in-person meeting with a delegation of opposition leaders. The delegation wanted to discuss concerns connected with the functioning of the Election Commission and related political issues. According to reports, the Chief Justice indicated that the concerns could be brought before the court through appropriate legal procedures rather than through a personal meeting. The decision became a subject of political criticism and public debate. Raut subsequently made remarks questioning the relationship between members of the judiciary and political figures. The petition filed by the SCBA refers to statements concerning judges allegedly attending political events and social gatherings. It also refers to social media content linked to claims about judges participating in a badminton event in London and a separate post referring to the burning of Albania’s Supreme Court. These references form part of the allegations raised by the petitioner. They should not be presented as established findings against Raut. The court will have to assess the relevant statements, their context and their legal significance before reaching any conclusion.

The Supreme Court has yet to deliver a final ruling on these allegations.

How Did Nikhil Wagle Become Involved in the Contempt Case? Journalist Nikhil Wagle is the other respondent named in the criminal contempt petition. His case concerns a social media post directed at CJI Surya Kant after the controversy over the proposed meeting with opposition leaders. During the October 28 hearing, senior advocate Indira Jaising, appearing for Wagle, informed the bench that her client had tendered an unconditional apology and removed the post. She also conveyed his willingness to participate in the proceedings. Wagle’s counsel requested permission for him to attend the next hearing virtually because he is based in Mumbai. The bench accepted the request and directed him to appear through video conferencing on November 17. The court also indicated that Wagle could be asked to appear physically at a later stage if considered necessary. His position differs procedurally from Raut’s. The court was informed during the hearing about Wagle’s apology, while Raut’s reported affidavit was not available on the record at that time. The bench consequently issued different directions concerning their attendance.

What Has the Supreme Court Bar Association Alleged?

The Supreme Court Bar Association brought the petition after raising concerns about remarks attributed to Raut and Wagle. It argued that the statements could affect the dignity and authority of the Supreme Court and the office of the Chief Justice. The association’s petition reportedly referred to public statements and social media posts that it considered objectionable. It also raised concerns about claims involving judges’ alleged attendance at political events and the circulation of material related to a badminton gathering in London. According to reports, the petitioner referred to an earlier Delhi High Court order concerning photographs circulated as showing judges playing badminton in London. The High Court had found that the images related to an event held at Delhi’s Thyagaraj Stadium in November 2025, rather than the event alleged in the circulated material, and had ordered the content to be removed. The SCBA relied on these and other statements in arguing that the remarks concerning the judiciary required judicial consideration. The association has also maintained that its action should not be interpreted as an attempt to prevent fair criticism of courts. Its central argument is that there is a difference between expressing disagreement with a judicial decision and making statements that may undermine the authority of the institution.

When Did the Contempt Proceedings Begin?

The legal process began before the October 28 hearing. On October 15, 2026, Attorney General R. Venkataramani gave written consent for the Supreme Court Bar Association to pursue criminal contempt proceedings against Raut and Wagle. The consent was granted under Section 15(1)(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971. The following day, October 16, the Supreme Court issued show-cause notices to both individuals. A show-cause notice asks the persons concerned to explain why further proceedings should not be initiated against them. At that stage, the court exempted them from personal appearance. The matter subsequently came before the bench of Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi on October 28. During that hearing, the court considered the status of the respondents’ responses and their attendance at the proceedings. After the hearing, the bench directed Raut to appear personally and permitted Wagle to participate virtually on the next date. This sequence is important because a show-cause notice is not the same as a finding of guilt. It is part of a legal process through which the court considers whether the allegations warrant further action.

What Is Criminal Contempt Under Indian Law?

Criminal contempt is a category of contempt of court recognised under Indian law. Section 2(c) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 sets out its definition, which includes certain publications or acts that scandalise or tend to scandalise a court, prejudice or interfere with judicial proceedings, or otherwise obstruct the administration of justice. The law is intended to protect the proper functioning of the judicial system and ensure that court proceedings are not improperly obstructed. However, it does not mean that every criticism of a judge, court order or judicial institution amounts to contempt. Courts must examine the words used, the surrounding circumstances, the nature of the publication and the applicable legal principles. Political commentary, criticism of public institutions and allegations concerning judicial conduct can raise difficult questions that require careful legal assessment. In a contempt case, the court must consider whether the conduct meets the statutory requirements. It must also assess the response of the person concerned and any apology submitted during the proceedings.

Why Is the November 17 Hearing Important?

The next hearing, scheduled for November 17, 2026, at 2 pm, will be an important procedural stage in the case. Raut has been directed to appear physically before the Supreme Court. Wagle has been permitted to join through video conferencing. The bench may consider the status of the affidavits, the submissions made by the parties and the next steps required to advance the proceedings. For Raut, the reported unconditional apology is likely to remain a key issue, but its legal effect cannot be assumed before the court considers it. The availability of the affidavit on the official record and the court’s assessment of its contents will be relevant to the next stage. For Wagle, the court may consider the apology and the removal of the social media post, alongside the wider circumstances of the case. The court has not yet announced a final decision on the proceedings against him either. The hearing may also help clarify how the bench intends to proceed with the broader allegations raised by the SCBA. However, it would be premature to predict that the case will be closed, that the apologies will be accepted or that any particular penalty will be imposed.

What Does the Case Mean for Freedom of Expression and Judicial Accountability?

The dispute has brought renewed attention to the relationship between freedom of expression and the legal protections afforded to the judiciary. Public officials, politicians, journalists and citizens routinely comment on court decisions and the conduct of public institutions. Such discussion can be an important part of democratic debate. At the same time, courts have legal mechanisms to address conduct that meets the threshold for contempt. The challenge is to distinguish criticism, even when strongly worded, from statements that satisfy the legal definition of criminal contempt. The context in which a remark is made, the factual basis for an allegation and the potential effect of a publication may all be relevant to that assessment. The case involving Raut and Wagle places these questions before the Supreme Court. The SCBA argues that the statements at issue go beyond legitimate criticism, while the court has yet to make a final determination on the allegations.

#Deshbaani News #India News #World news #Global News
Sponsored
Trending News
Bihar Celebrates Kartik Chhath Conclusion as Millions Offer Prayers

Bihar Celebrates Kartik Chhath Conclusion as Millions Offer ...

Kartik Chhath concludes in Bihar as millions of devotees offer prayers to the rising Sun, completing

Nov. 16, 2026 3:27 p.m. 133
Diljit Dosanjh Responds to Critics at Indore Concert With Powerful Message

Diljit Dosanjh Responds to Critics at Indore Concert With Po...

Diljit Dosanjh quotes Rahat Indori in Indore, responding to criticism, song restrictions and securit

Nov. 16, 2026 3:13 p.m. 129
Dhanteras 2026: India Expects Over β‚Ή1 Lakh Crore in Business

Dhanteras 2026: India Expects Over β‚Ή1 Lakh Crore in Business...

Dhanteras 2026 may generate over β‚Ή1 lakh crore in India, with Gold and Silver sales estimated above

Nov. 6, 2026 11:44 a.m. 157
Cyclone Arnab Triggers Heavy Rain Alert Across Jharkhand

Cyclone Arnab Triggers Heavy Rain Alert Across Jharkhand...

Cyclone Arnab brings heavy rain to Jharkhand as officials warn of strong winds, lightning and furthe

Oct. 29, 2026 3 p.m. 192
Jio Platforms Shares Make Strong Market Debut at 21.36% Premium

Jio Platforms Shares Make Strong Market Debut at 21.36% Prem...

Jio Platforms lists at β‚Ή1,358, a 21.36% premium. Explore IPO subscription, market cap, financial res

Oct. 28, 2026 4:11 p.m. 196
Cyclone Arnab Threatens Andhra Coast as Flights and Trains Face Disruption

Cyclone Arnab Threatens Andhra Coast as Flights and Trains F...

Cyclone Arnab threatens Andhra Pradesh with strong winds and heavy rain, disrupting flights at three

Oct. 28, 2026 12:58 p.m. 214
IndiGo Extends Saudi Flight Cancellations Amid Security Concerns

IndiGo Extends Saudi Flight Cancellations Amid Security Conc...

Saudi Arabia flight cancellations continue amid security concerns. IndiGo suspends Riyadh flights un

Oct. 24, 2026 3:05 p.m. 205
Tibet Earthquake: 16 Dead, 32 Injured as 7.0 Quake Hits Nagqu

Tibet Earthquake: 16 Dead, 32 Injured as 7.0 Quake Hits Nagq...

A 7.0-magnitude earthquake struck Tibet, killing 16 and injuring 32. Rescue teams continue searching

Oct. 23, 2026 11:26 a.m. 165